ZDNet Home PageSm@rt Reseller Online Win a BMW Z3!

January 25, 1999

arrowBreaking News
arrowIssue Index

arrowBook Reviews
arrowOnline Resellers
arrowWindows 2000
arrowE-Biz Zone

Seagate: Click Here

arrowEd Sperling
arrowMary Jo Foley
arrowGary A. Bolles
arrowRich & Dave
arrowGovt. Witness
arrowMind Your Biz

arrowSR Masthead
arrowEdit Calendar
arrowContact Us
arrowAd Marketplace

arrowIndustry Events
arrowSm@rt IQ

Subscribe to SR!

Download the best shareware NOW - click here!


Linux Up Close: Time To Switch

Commercial Linux releases are ready for your server business.

By Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols & Eric Carr, Sm@rt Reseller

arrowThe Best Windows File Server: Linux!
arrowLinux Is The Web Server's Choice
arrowHow They Stack Up
arrowTALK BACK and post your comments online!
arrowLinux Infopack

arrowInfopack Index
arrowBreaking News
arrowSm@rt Opinions
arrowSR Home Page
Forget Linux's hype. Forget Microsoft Corp.'s server market share. The bottom line, according to our hands-on analysis, is that commercial Linux releases can do much more with far less than Windows NT Server can.

Yes, Linux has its problems as a desktop operating system. Yes, NT and NetWare have staggering brand recognition. But Linux is a worthy contender--both in features and performance--for your customers' file and Internet server jobs.

Not all Linux systems, however, are created equal. While Linux is an open-source operating system that anyone can download from the Internet and then compile, our testing clearly shows that there are significant differences among the three commercial Linux releases: Caldera Systems Inc.'s OpenLinux 1.3, Red Hat Software Inc.'s Red Hat Linux 5.2 and SuSE Inc.'s SuSE Linux 5.3.

Those three Linux offerings are based on the open-source Linux source code. So almost any given Linux program--along with most Santa Cruz Operation Inc. Unix apps--will run on any version of Linux. A program's performance, however, can vary from Linux release to Linux release, depending on how an app was compiled.

How We Tested Our test platform was a pair of identically configured and outfitted 266MHz PCs. Each had 64MB of memory and a 4GB IDE disk drive. An Intel Corp. EtherExpress Pro 100B network interface card connected the server to our client network, which is driven by a pair of Synoptics (now Nortel Networks) 28115 Fast Ethernet switches. All tests ran at a network speed of 100Mbps. In each instance, we performed a fresh install of the operating system. We let the operating system decide the default disk configuration in each case. In other words, we didn't try to tweak any settings. (Our guess is that results would have been even more embarrassing if we had.)

We measured the throughput of up to 30 clients for each server. The clients were a mix of 166MHz, 200MHz and 233MHz machines running Windows 95. Each of the clients ran the WebBench 2.0 static test workload to measure http server performance and NetBench 5.01 for Server Message Block (SMB), or file service, testing. Both benchmarks are available free from www.zdbop.com.

We configured each of the Linux boxes to run Samba (the SMB server) and Apache (the Web server)--but that's it. We weren't running DNS or Sendmail. Since they were being evaluated as servers, the Linux boxes were not running the X display system. The NT box was running Internet Information Server 4.0 under NT 4.0 with Service Pack 4. Again, no additional services were running.

According to ZDLabs' results (see test charts), each of the commercial Linux releases ate NT's lunch. Our tests also revealed that Apache for OpenLinux is superior to Apache for Red Hat and SuSE. Moreover, Samba for Red Hat scales better than its counterparts.

Look Under The Hood Every commercial Linux comes with a mind-boggling assortment of open-source programs. If you want file servers, you get your choice of Network File System- or Wintel-compliant Samba. If you want the Internet, you got it. Need a graphical user interface? Start with X-Windows and then add the window manager of your customers' choice.

Can't find the program you want on the provided CD-ROMs? Download it from the Internet, compile it and run it. For our tests, we downloaded the GNU Mailman mailing-list manager--a Python programming language application--and compiled and ran it successfully on all three Linux platforms.

While Python isn't included in the commercial distributions, a host of other language tools and compilers are. These include C, C++ and Perl. For custom development right out of the box, you can't beat Linux.

Of course, open-source programs and development tools aren't the only thing Linux has going for it. When your customers crave database-management systems, they can take their pick among offerings from Software AG, Informix Corp., Oracle Corp. and Sybase Inc.. In short, you name a server application type, and it's in there.

Unlike NT or NetWare, however, getting the application up and running--because apps often must be compiled--can be more difficult. It's a trade-off. With NT or NetWare, you receive an easier-to-install binary. With Linux, you get a tougher install but considerably more control over the application.

Linux system administrators need not be programmers, though. The Redhat Package Manager (RPM) has become a de facto standard for application installation.

That said, you will need to be aware of such issues as what C library is supported in which distribution. Red Hat, for example, has moved its programs to Glibc 2, the latest version of the GNU C library, while OpenLinux and SuSE binaries, as of version 5.3, still depend on the libc5 runtime library. Translation: Some RPM binaries will fail on OpenLinux and SuSE systems.

The further evolution of Linux--a new base version of the code, 2.2, will debut shortly--will help remove such problems. For now, though, Linux resellers need to be aware of program-compatibility issues.

One undeniable advantage of NT, however, is that ISVs are far more likely to produce programs for it. That said, unless a customer wants a specific brand name, there's little functionality available in commercial software that's not available in a Linux program.

Caldera's LinuxSlim Code Just for kicks, we successfully loaded and ran all three commercial Linuxes on 33MHz 486 and 66MHz 486DX2 systems with 500MB hard drives and 16MB of memory. For customers with limited hardware budgets, Linux can be a godsend.

Where Linux does fall behind, however, is driver support and hardware discovery. Although Linux hardware support is improving, you must check each version's supported hardware list to be certain that all of your customers' components will function properly.

In our tests, we found, for example, that OpenLinux couldn't find our Intel EtherExpress Pro/100B network interface card and none of the three could locate our EtherExpress Pro/10+ cards.

Difficult Installation OpenLinux, with its Linux Installation and System Administration, had the roughest install. Red Hat took the honors for the smoothest install. For network administrators, though, SuSE is the more compelling choice. SuSE wins because of its Yet another Setup Tool (YaST). This administration and installation tool centralizes many administration and network services into an easy-to-use interface. It's the best all-in-one Linux management tool by a long shot.

Documentation remains a problem with all these distributions. Administrators familiar with the Unix online manual will find themselves at home. Others will want to pick up a Linux book at the local bookstore or from Amazon.com.

Once installed, all the Linux platforms performed like champs. We never encountered a single crash over the course of several weeks of testing. Network operating system stability has a new name--Linux.

Linux Lessons So which Linux will work for your customers? From a business standpoint, the nod goes to Caldera. Its reseller program is heads and shoulders above the others (more on that in a moment). In addition, its superior NetWare compatibility--with the use of Caldera's NetWare for Linux package--makes it a compelling choice for converting existing NetWare networks.

Alas, Caldera's distribution has a few kinks in it. While OpenLinux is the best Web server platform, Red Hat holds the lead in straightforward file serving, and both SuSE and Red Hat are easier to install and manage.

Keep in mind that SuSE Linux 6.0 should be released in English by the time you read this. And since the base Linux code will be updated shortly, your best move is to download and evaluate each system for yourself.

Reseller's Linux Technical superiority is all well and good, but can you make money with Linux? The answer is yes, but you can't do it by relying on box-sales margins. With Linux, there is none worth speaking of. Instead, your path to profitability must be through consulting, installation and support services.

Support is job one for would-be Linux resellers. While Linux is more stable than NT, it, and many of its most common open-source applications, is in constant evolution. Customers that want to get the most from their networks will need hands-on system and application administrators.

Linux support, as is often trumpeted, is widely available from the Linux online community. A customer fuming at a RAID controller that's out of control, however, isn't going to wait for a helpful answer from the Usenet newsgroup comp.os.linux.hardware. That customer will want an answer immediately, and that's where you come in.

Where do you get that information? Ask your employees, who should be experienced Linux users. If you don't have a Linux guru on staff, comb the local college campuses for a potential hire. Linux is hot in academia. And don't forget to lean on the Linux vendors for support. Vendor support used to be limited to a less than sterling 30 to 90 days after registration. Now, both Caldera and Red Hat offer per-incident and annual subscription support packages.

Turn To Caldera The reseller leader is Caldera. Besides the usual price breaks and marketing help, Caldera's long reseller history is sprinkled with comprehensive reseller training courses, an open discussion reseller-only mailing list and an online bimonthly publication. In addition, Caldera was the first vendor to offer Linux technical training, available at a 50 percent discount for resellers, and a certification program, the Certified Linux Engineer. Finally, Caldera offers two reseller levels: the Authorized Partner tier for entry-level resellers and the Business Partner for resellers that know Unix and NetWare.

Red Hat is close behind Caldera. It has disclosed plans for co-marketing, co-branding, training and vendor certification. To date, however, only the marketing and branding plans are in place. Red Hat offers two reseller paths. The first, Authorized System Builders, is for white-box resellers interested in building Red Hat Linux boxes. The other, Authorized Value Added Resellers, is for resellers focused on consulting and custom IT solutions.

Following the others is Germany's SuSE. The company is actively building up its reseller program, but for the most part you'll be on your own. SuSE, while dominant in Europe, is still feeling out its way in North America and doesn't have training or certification in place yet. What it does have, however, is phone technical support via LinuxCare Inc., a major Linux help-desk operation.

Can any of those offerings compete with Microsoft's 800-pound gorilla of a reseller organization? Of course not. That's not important. What is important is that there's finally enough of a channel infrastructure in place to make Linux a viable choice for any network reseller willing to make a commitment to the maverick operating system.

Talkback Articles
Post TalkBack
 This is an excellent art... - Craig Goodrich
 Thanks for the Linux vs ... - Dave Adams
 Could you include someth... - Adrian Filipi-Martin
 Objective results are go... - Chuck Moss
 Now lets put FreeBSD int... - coward
 1 user slower than NT? ... - Andy Green
 More of this stuff pleas... - Kevin Forge
  Great article !!! I... - Ed Hill
 A minor detail, but want... - Miles Clark
 Why didn't you publish t... - David Steuber
 Yes please publish FreeB... - coward II
 Oh. It's in the side ba... - David Steuber
 Comment on lack of docum... - Jeremy Miller
 You can find links to th... - Eric Carr
 FreeBSD had a speed adva... - Free GNUlixD
 Did you recompile the ke... - Addison Laurent
 The difference of the ht... - Krakken
 How often did NT crash?... - Mark Hammer
 Nice job. I think this i... - Scott Anderson
 Pay more attention to De... - Ean Schuessler
 Redhat supports appletal... - Paul Tice
 One more request: I woul... - N. Crosby
 My notebook is running a... - Andy Lee
 I wonder how you found t... - Keith Baker
 A few notes -- Python co... - Richard Benedict Gates
 Fantastic article! No... - Jeffrey P Rose
 What about Debian? I ... - Samuel Scarano
 What Happened to Slackwa... - Ted Sikora
 Um, Appletalk DOES come ... - Roberto Pavan
 THe real funny part of t... - Don Mickinson
 "Documentation remains a... - Voudras
 Let us stay focused. Lin... - Farkas
 Caldera??? COL is lib... - Clancy Dalebout
 While it's nice to see a... - Rob Thiemann
 Python is in there. W... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 We have a Mac OS X revie... - Esther Schindler
 Compilers, Samba and Fre... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 re: Redhat and hardware ... - Calvin Dodge
 Re: NT crashes & Debian ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 The $50-60 price tags fo... - Steve Koppelman
 I want to second the opi... - jim arnold
 80386SX works as well. ... - Bernard Murray
 Linux in a matchbox. I ... - Bernard Murray
 How about a similar stud... - Fred Springfield
 Time for more benchmark.... - SL Tan
 Finally, some Real Data.... - David Wilson
 EtherExpress Pro/100B ne... - Vaibhav Vaish
 What happens at the 200+... - Dominic Baines
 I'll have to save this f... - Scott
 libc5 is simple to fix..... - GreyFauk
 Nice article, but some e... - Andreas Hupfau
 Thank you !! At last a ... - Thomas Wickline
 A great comparison ! ... - Johan Brichau
 Yahoo seems to prefer Fr... - Mark Blackman
 Great article, its very ... - Kevin Pesce
 You guys should try Debi... - Paul Stroud
 Come to think of it...Yo... - Me again
 At last an article like ... - kris carlier
 Last year, on May 9th, a... - Jerry Kreps
 This may make me ver unp... - mR GIbbEd
 Linux Rocks. I'm glad to... - T. Nathan Mundhenk
 Thank you for this excel... - Tim Hanson
 Article Idea: Fully twe... - Greg McGee
 Hello: I think this w... - L. S. Colby
 Also keep in mind that l... - brian
 Linux does look great. ... - Lewis A. Mettler, Esq.
 As a Linux user, I was e... - Seth McQuale
 You forgot reliability. ... - Mitch Pirtle
 Aren't you breaking the ... - none available
 I think it is immoral an... - Jown Almanag
 Distributions and tweaki... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 So far in the last 4 yea... - Anita Crawford
 Appletalk support adds f... - Deirdre Saoirse
 I've been so frustrated ... - Sean Clark
 Python is, indeed, inclu... - David Goldstein
 SuSe is not the weakest ... - Atif Ghaffar
 Either Linux or FreeBSD ... - Donald Wilde
 The ext2 file system use... - David J. Owens
 This article was great a... - keith broere
 shame OS/2 wasn't includ... - voytek eymont
 Yes, Voytek, we'll do an... - Esther Schindler
 Just as an aside, Linux ... - Nathan Spitzer
 Anent Caldera v. Redhat.... - jcowen

NT slowed by vi... - Michel Merlin

 What about Slackware? S... - Jonathan Feldman
 Just what I've been wait... - Stan Czerno
 To Michael Merlin: Th... - James Leeds Jr.
 Michel Merlin: as far as... - Andrew Norris
 I think that the Linux i... - Luciano S. Pinheiro Jr.
 NT Slowed by video? Y... - Clint Cone
 i am amazed... i'm a lon... - paranoid android
  I am not a Microsoft su... - Scott Wright
 I too would like to see ... - Lee Roth
  Unfortunately I ... - Darryl Baker
 When they get setup, fil... - Michael S Sartor Sr
 Prognostication for Wind... - Tom
 Excellent article. It's ... - Eivind Kjørstad
 What version of Samba wa... - Arun Khan
 Re: Scott Wright && !(Mi... - Michael O'Keefe
 Linux isn't free. When y... - arielb
 LINUX=FREE Linux is f... - toni
 486-33 Linux outperforme... - David Roland
 Sorry, but all you Linux... - joseph flowers
 The commercial versions,... - Mark LaRosa
 You may end up with less... - Juan Carlos Castro y Castro
 I've lost count of the n... - Adam Slagle
 To arielb: Get your fact... - Dave Lambert
 My NT servers DO NOT cra... - Dan Swogger
 It is good to see an opt... - J.D.
 With respect to Joseph F... - Curtis Sorenson
 To Arielb The whole p... - Nathan Woodhull
 Have you tested or compa... - Brian Gamble
 Thanks for the AMMO... - Terry Mills
 Apples and Oranges. N... - Jawaid Bazyar
 You can't publish this -... - Dan Lewis
 OK, Esther, some real li... - voytek eymont
 Public Apology My pre... - Dan Lewis
 Sure NT might have been ... - David Schwartz
 Full ACLs for filesystem... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 This is obvious, everyon... - Jeff...
 Re: Joseph Flowers... I ... - Anthony E. Greene
 Have you seen the "so ca... - Kyler Jones
 Great article, if a bit ... - Eric Hillman
 I'm curious how Linux & ... - Jesse
 I was sad to see that u ... - Pedro
 What about Netware? ... - Janet Ross
 Debian GNU/Linux is eleg... - Art Lemasters
 SUSE 5.3 does have Glibc... - Morden
 This is a great article,... - Tor Sigurdsson
 Excellent article on Lin... - Chris Geske
 Great text! I tried m... - Marcus Borelli Ribeiro
 BeOS also.. Please do th... - Tim Mayville
 BeOS also.. Please do th... - T. Mayville
 it's a pity that netware... - Lennart Lemon
 For those of you that ar... - Dan R. Gowin
 Memory > 64MB? This was... - Brady Hegberg
 As pointed out by someon... - Bronson Messer
 Why compare different di... - Erik Johnsson
 Caldera, RedHat and Suse... - Jimmy Presto
 You say "Yes, Linux has ... - Anonymous Coward
 Thanks for the interesti... - Mike Belshe
 > Curious < Curious..... - Lord Spurius
 Its is interesting to se... - Richard Corfield
 Netware and IPX We'll... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Re: GUI affecting the sp... - Daniel C. Miller
 I use Linux on a second ... - Bob Leslie
 I believe your stats are... - danny
 can it run all my softwa... - Bob Gratton
 Great article, but why d... - John Carline
 Paul Tice doesn't know w... - Guido
 I have been using Linux ... - Donald H. Bennett
 Bob Leslie makes a good ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Excellant Article on Lin... - Bill Webber
 I feel that Netscape 4.... - jack chen
 Linux works for me. I h... - Jason Foster
 How often in the history... - Frank Meyer
 Windows? Consider KDE. ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 This is a terrible artic... - dan houck
 One problem with a strai... - d. marks
 joseph flowers posted: ... - Richard Turner
 Great Article! I've used... - Gary H. Rittinger
 With respect to Michel M... - Glen Parker
 Linux v. NT, RAM Usage, ... - Kyle Sparger
 I liked the article very... - Aaron Saikovski
 This article doesn't pro... - Boris Dynin
 One technical error I no... - David Buddrige
 RE:NT slowed by video? ... - anonymous
 It is getting easer to u... - Joe Davenport
 I enjoyed reading the ar... - Darrell Sullivan
 Cost of next 10 copies? ... - Ross Johnson
 Quoting Joseph Flowers: ... - William Kitchen
 >> plans to compare LINU... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 RPM is not the defacto s... - John Culleton
 Linux was doomed from co... - Ken Hack
 I've sent this URL to ma... - 'Aztec Eagle' Turbo
 I've sent this URL to ma... - 'Aztec Eagle' Turbo
 Yes Linux is great and I... - Larry Vaughn
 hi Ken! afraid of loo... - Johann Hautzinger
 This was a little too si... - Jason Hartzell
 Amen Jason All we seem t... - Jim Maddox
 More talk?? Come on, ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 You Are All FOOLS...COL ... - VoodooXpert
 Linux is a great alterna... - Jeff R.
 Hey Red! Congratulations... - Tracey Congdon
 Why wont you damn magazi... - Michael Warnock
 no one tests Debian out ... - Jason
 All EtherExpress cards (... - Roy Stogner
 This article was very co... - Chris Jackson
 It is amazing to see art... - Dennis Forbes
 Where's FreeBSD? FreeBSD... - Steve Neuharth
 Quote from the article: ... - Martin Skøtt
 What fun... Now peopl... - Fabien Penso
 The version of the Ether... - David Wollmann
 Although I'm a huge fan ... - Joe Johnston
 MS free at last! I've b... - Bryan Scaringe
 NT kills Linux! In the c... - Mike Edwards
 M.C.S.E. Must Consult So... - MSCE
 I love to read comments ... - jds
 Debian is the best relea... - NatePuri
 Where is FreeBSD? Your c... - Tony Fiorentino
 To Ken Hack: Wow! Woul... - Alex Van De Putte
 People like Joseph Flore... - Adilson Oliveira
 FreeBSD is a better prof... - Donald Wilde
 Of course, the person wh... - PinkFreud
 Make Linux easier to use... - Stuart McDow
 All the people who want ... - Chris Goodwin
 FreeBSD should be part o... - Brett Glass
 While I understand that ... - Bryan Van de Ven
 Esther Schindler writes:... - Jorge
 To the Microsoft apologi... - Scott Prive
 Linux is bood For U !!! ... - Kap Keu
 What's Linux? Oh yeah..... - Joseph Garcia
 Add 64MB, NT wins the a... - dave
 Add 64MB? Yes? Sorry, ... - Alex Van De Putte
 It's nice to here about ... - Prakash Kadam
 re: COMPLETELY IRRESPONS... - Stalker Marker
 Multiple CPUS would be a... - David Boosalis
 So someone finally notic... - Martin Lebl
 All of you who give comp... - Mike
 I find it interesting an... - Mike Bolser
 An interesting thing I'v... - Rich James
 RE: RE: COMPLETELY IRRES... - Jeremy Horton
 Is MTIC a Linux investme... - Blake Edwards
 Linux vs. NT, one datum.... - mike connolly
 Thanks for the article. ... - Jeffrey S. Sharp
 NT's default optimizatio... - Chris Falter
 To Mike Bolser! thank y... - Alex Van De Putte
 Re: This article doesn'... - K. Eisenhower
 BOLLOCKS , How come cald... - Simon
 Article spurs my interes... - Ron Gregory
 It is very obvious that ... - Mike Martin
 To d. marks; Check out p... - Doke Scott
 See th... - Brett Glass
 Is this thing going forw... - Dan Swogger
 Python _is_ distributed ... - Michael B. Allen
 Good Article, the facts ... - Santiago
 Arielb: Linux isn't fre... - Andrew
 Benchmarks All Wrong? ... - Sunny Hirai
 I can't believe that Lin... - Tim Greer
 I'm sure that Linux and ... - Denny Wyss
 >>However, I find it har... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Serious business' use NT... - Jon Andre Chun
 I've been using NetBench... - Don Olsen
 You say that Linux ate N... - Ian Thompson
 You say that Linux ate N... - Ian Thompson
 Network printing! One of... - David Jarrell
 Re: NetBench results ... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Network printing. It'... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Steven, Your response... - Sunny Hirai
 The real power of Linux ... - Michael L Lockhart
 Linux will never catch o... - William Keyser
  Any chance of testin... - Curt Humphrey
  Any chance of testin... - Curt Humphrey
 Add 64MB of RAM!!!!!!! ... - Jason Hartzell
 Completely Irresponsible... - Jason Hartzell
 I can only speak direclt... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Turbo Linux. Funny yo... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Steven, I fully respe... - Sunny Hirai
 Since the machine you us... - Luca Cheli
 No tuning of any kind wa... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 No tuning of any kind wa... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 "No tuning . . ."???? ... - Dan Swogger
 To all those NT fanatics... - Greg Thomas
 "Is this thing going for... - Greg Thomas
 No tuning is the only wa... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Slackware Linux should h... - Ashley
 With all due respect, Gr... - Sunny Hirai
 Samba: I have used Linux... - Todd Knauer
 >>Is there a Samba inter... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Good article but what ab... - Rob Darwin
 To Joseph Flowers: Ki... - Dustin
 I would like to see a co... - Matt Linn
 The real winner, Netware... - Marv Falk
 You want Netware results... - Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
 Linux is too good .... c... - Amitabh Saxena
 I find your comments on ... - Rick Gipson

SR HomearrowInfopack Index

Reviews | News | Downloads | Shop | MyZDNet | Games | ZDTV | Forums

AnchorDesk | PC Magazine | PC Week | Help! | Yahoo! Internet Life

Copyright © 1997-99 Ziff-Davis Inc. All Rights Reserved. Please read ZDNet's Privacy Statement.

WIN  A FREE Toshiba Laptop!
WIN  A FREE Toshiba Laptop!
Resellers  Seagate RESELLERS! Register here for a FREE COMDEX TRIP.
Resellers  Membership NOW has its benefits, Quantum Access is here
Software  X10.com -- The SuperSite for Home Automation
Books  Get the Hottest New Computer and Technology Books!
Freebies!  50 FREE downloads -- the top programs of the year
Shop & Save  How-To-Buy Guides: Find the best deals online
Top Tips  Optimize your PC with this week's Top 50 Tips from ZDHelp
Free Issue  Get a risk-free issue of RED HERRING magazine today!

APC Sweepstakes!